Carriage garage doors remind us of the traditional carriage house or a coach house. It is an outbuilding which was originally built to house horse-drawn carriages and their related tack. They feature a distinctive appearance, resembling the swinging doors of these carriage houses. This style of garage doors today often look like these classic doors that open at the center, though most roll up and down like the modern overhead garage doors. The authentic carriage garage doors are defined by how they open and how they are made: they swing out and it’s made by frame-and-panel construction. The frame is made of vertical grain wood that is a crucial factor in limiting moisture absorption. The precision of the close fit when closing the doors makes it a great seal from the weather. 

Typically made from wood or materials that look like wood, carriage-style doors have that classic wood look. They often feature raised panels or intricate patterns that add to their old-fashioned vibe. You’ll also find decorative elements like windows, iron accents, hinges, and handles. While these features add to the authentic look, they are often just for display, enhancing the door’s style without affecting its operation. In this article, we feature the best carriage garage doors available in the market:

Raynor RockCreeke™ Carriage House Garage Door

What we love:

• Customizable woodgrain finishes
• Superior thermal efficiency
• Authentic carriage house design
• Durable steel construction
• Advanced WeatherLock™ system
• Quiet operation with optional TruBalance™ drum system

The Raynor RockCreeke™ Carriage House Residential Garage Door features customizable woodgrain finishes that give the door a genuine wooden appearance. It has superior thermal efficiency, achieved through its polyurethane insulation. Built with durable steel, this door is designed to withstand the elements and be long-lasting. The advanced WeatherLock™ system seals out the harshest weather conditions, ensuring your garage and belongings stay protected. It also has the optional TruBalance™ drum system that minimizes noise during operation. The authentic carriage house design, coupled with its modern features, makes the Raynor RockCreeke™ an excellent choice for homeowners who want both style and function in their garage doors.

Read the full review >>

Clopay Coachman®

What we love:

• Four-layer construction for durability
• Polystyrene or Intellicore® insulation options
• WindCode® reinforcement for added security
• Wide range of design and color options
• Low-maintenance composite overlay

The Clopay Coachman has an elegant vintage style complemented by four-layer construction, ensuring that the door is built to last. Homeowners can choose between polystyrene or Intellicore® insulation, both providing excellent thermal efficiency to keep the garage comfortable in any season. Coachman features WindCode® reinforcement to withstand high winds and improve overall safety. With a wide range of design and color options, you can customize the door to perfectly match your home’s exterior. The low-maintenance composite overlay mimics the look of wood without the upkeep. The Clopay Coachman is a versatile and reliable choice for homeowners who want a stylish and sturdy door for their garage.

Read the full review >>

Amarr Carriage Court

What we love:

• Heavy-duty steel construction
• Unique carriage house designs
• Superior energy efficiency with insulation options
• WindPro™ wind load reinforcement
• SafeGuard pinch protection
• Customizable decorative hardware

The Amarr Carriage Court garage door is built with heavy-duty steel construction to ensure long-lasting durability while maintaining the classic look of a traditional carriage house door. Homeowners can choose from a variety of unique carriage house designs that enhance the with superior energy efficiency achieved through multiple insulation options. Equipped with WindPro™ wind load reinforcement, this door is built to withstand strong winds. Safety is also a top priority, with SafeGuard pinch protection designed to reduce the risk of injuries. Lastly, the customizable decorative hardware allows you to personalize the door to suit your style.

Read the full review >>

C.H.I. Overhead Doors Stamped Carriage House Model 5283

What we love:

• Durable steel construction
• Polystyrene insulation
• Four base colors and customizable window options
• Heavy-duty hardware for enhanced durability
• Optional WindBreaker™ reinforcement system

The C.H.I. Overhead Doors Stamped Carriage House Model 5283 features a timeless carriage house design combined with modern durability. This door is constructed from high-quality steel, ensuring it can withstand the rigors of daily use. The polystyrene insulation provides excellent thermal performance. Available in four base colors and with a variety of customizable window options, the Model 5283 can be customized to complement your home’s exterior. For those in areas prone to high winds, the optional WindBreaker™ is an option offered as reinforcement system.

Read the full review >>

Conclusion

When choosing a carriage-style garage door, consider the material, insulation, security, and style. Wood doors have an authentic vintage look but require more maintenance, while steel doors with wood finishes provide durability with less upkeep. Insulation is important for temperature control, so look for doors with options like polystyrene or polyurethane insulation. Security features, such as wind load reinforcement, are crucial, especially in areas prone to harsh weather. The models discussed above meet these considerations well. The Raynor RockCreeke™ has customizable woodgrain finishes and superior thermal efficiency. The Clopay Coachman combines style with modern durability and insulation options. The Amarr Carriage Court features heavy-duty construction, multiple insulation choices, and safety features. Lastly, the C.H.I. Overhead Doors Stamped Carriage House Model 5283 has a classic design, excellent thermal performance, and customizable options. Each of these doors balances good appearance with practical functionality.